Give Linux a chance

12 May 2008

Mughlai and Jalfrezi are better than gruel

A few hundred years ago, the great mass of the British poor ate gruel, while the middle class ate bland over-boiled vegetables. However, as a naval people, the British went out around the world with their empire, and brought food and foreign chefs back with them. Now British people can and do eat food originating from the whole world. Not just the rich, normal working class people will regularly eat curry, Cantonese food, kebabs and so on that would not have been imaginable before.

If I tried to explain this to a 14th Century peasant eating his gruel, then he probably would just ignore me, having no idea what I am talking about. At best he might look at me strangely, and then go back to his life of gruel.

Windows is the gruel of the digital world. There are certain people that understand this fact and have moved on to greater and better things, however most people take what they are given and swallow it as best they can.

What is an operating system?

If you don't know what a computer program is, think about cooking. In cooking you have tools, such as an oven and a blender and you have ingredients such as vegetables and meat. The recipe allows you to use the tools to take your food (ingredients) and turn them into to other types of food (meals).

In computers, you have tools (called hardware) such as a DVD player, a screen, a keyboard, a hard drive and so on. The computer program is the mathematical recipe that allows you to take your data (text, pictures, videos, etc) and then do various things with it. So for example, you might use a computer program that takes a song from the hard-drive and then plays it out of the speakers.

An operating system is a set of computer programs that makes your computer hardware do the basic things (put text on the screen, play sound, and so on). You might then run other programs to do more advanced things. It is like your recipe book.

People who are in to cooking will try out lots of recipe books, and in doing so, they do not starve because they have bought a different recipe book, indeed the opposite happens, they cook so much that they do not have time to eat it all themselves so have to give food to their family and neighbours.

By changing recipe book, they don't suddenly become unable to cook, they in fact get better as they move on to better and more advanced recipe books.

If you turn on you computer and see Windows, then Windows is your current 'operating system'. If you have only ever used Windows, don't you think it is time to give up the gruel and try a new recipe book?

I think so, and if you think this way then you have come to the right place!

About Windows

Windows started on home computers and was commonly used for playing computer games. Though some shifty business deals in the 1980s and 1990s, Windows became pre-installed on the PC and so became the main operating system used by non-technical users.

However, there a lot of people that think that this situation is not good for humanity and we need to progress past it.

Why? Well lets look at some of the reasons.

Firstly, Windows does not promote a competitive industry. Only Microsoft can sell Windows, only Microsoft can really provide complete support for Windows. Mainstream PC shops may only stock Windows PCs.

So you have one company earning billions of their monopoly, with these excess profits, Microsoft can then give campaign contributions to politicians to make sure they don't make the industry competitive or hold Microsoft to account when they break the law.

Weak, bribed, politicians allow Microsoft to use the educational system as a giant marketing tool, indoctrinating a new generation to become helpless and passive recipients of Microsoft's, and only Microsoft's, products.

Secondly, each version of Windows is developed in secret, and then launched with billions of dollars worth of marketing to make you believe the magic; however like all magic, it is no replacement for public peer review. Microsoft don't like public peer review because they know that when compared fairly to other operating systems, Windows always loses.

The fact that there is no public peer review, and no effective competitive pressures, means that Windows is not very well engineered. When the main architecture of DOS and Windows was created in the 80s, it was already 20 years behind the state of computer science; and it has not really changed that much since.

This 'closed-off from the world in my own cave' approach to software engineering means that Windows is plagued with security problems, it uses computer resources inefficiently, wasting electricity and requiring unnecessary replacement of perfectly fine computers that could have lasted another five to ten years.

Fourthly, a software mono-culture, like a biological monoculture, is not very healthy. If a future Windows virus wipes out all of the world's Windows PCs, then 90% of the computer using population are offline, without their data and without access to government services, Internet commerce and digital information. Businesses would collapse and the western world would be plunged into a digital dark age.

Fourthly, because what Windows is doing is a secret; if you use Windows, then you are not in control of your computer, Microsoft is. Windows reports back lots of data to the USA which is then made available to whomever Microsoft wants to share it with. While most of us are not interesting to the US security agencies; Microsoft can sell your private information to anyone.

In short, Windows leaves your backdoor open to Microsoft, but even if you trust Microsoft, the US government, and all companies that Microsoft might sell your information too; the fact there are built-in backdoors means that anyone, criminals, terrorists, anyone, can potentially walk through Microsoft's backdoor to access your private data or install viruses or tracking software on your PC.

There is another way...

...Indeed there are lots of them! The opposite to Windows slavery is software freedom. And with freedom comes lots of choices, and choices are good! If you have spent a lifetime eating gruel then you might resent choice, but then remember the intolerant character in Dr Seuss' classic "Green Eggs and Ham", who resists and resists trying out new things for unjustified reasons.

The operating system I currently use is GNU/Linux (commonly just called Linux), which started out in Universities and parts were contributed by thousands of volunteers over the world wide web; others soon joined in, such as small and large companies, charities and even the American military.

Unlike Windows, any company or individual can share, sell, give away or provide services for GNU/Linux, anyone can change it, and there is complete public peer review. There are no hidden traps and you are in control of your own computer.

Also the way Linux executes programs is based on a completely different architecture. There is no concept of an untrusted, unknown program having access to everything. The problems that plague Windows, viruses, spywhere, malware and worms, do not exist in the Linux world. They have never existed and will never exist, because the architecture of the system is not designed that way.

So as I said before, anyone can give out Linux, so lots of people do (remember: choice is good) most versions are free and you can legally share them with your friends and neighbours without having to ask anyone.

Give it a go!

1 Brendan says...

Indeed! Go Forth and conquer...

Posted at 9:52 p.m. on May 13, 2008


2 justin says...

The day after I read this I discussed Linux with a group of professionals, only one of whom had ever heard of it. As a happy Linux user I was glad to plant some seeds for thought among the group.

Posted at 6:14 a.m. on May 18, 2008


3 Garrick says...

Most times when I bring up the wonders of Linux (and other UNIX like operating systems) people just stare at me blankly and ask "why does Microsoft allow them to do that?".

Posted at 1:54 p.m. on May 22, 2008


4 Tris says...

Justin - You say they had not heard of Linux? That doesn't sound very professional to me!

Posted at 10:14 p.m. on July 8, 2008


5 Nui says...

Hmm, this would be more persuasive as an argument with some evidence. I am a happy admin of Windows and a novice user of Linux, so I have taken the plunge, but this is really biased. Windows was always a work tool, there really was no significant games market initially for Windows!

Linux is a good piece of kit but there are many things it does not do too well. It is not very user friendly despite recent improvements to some distros, especially Ubuntu etc. This is what Windows does well. Security on the other hand is not as good in Windows but getting better year after year. So yeah give Linux a go but you might want to dual boot and have the best of both worlds.

Oh and be fair, prejudice is no good for anyone nor is a reverse snobbery towards Windows.

Posted at 4:48 p.m. on July 18, 2008


6 Double Booting Bastard says...

I agree with Nui, Linux is great for many things but not everything. A lot of, less mainstream, hardware is a time consuming and often fruitless task to install and even distros like Ubuntu lack the simplicity of use that keeps Windows on the throne. Linux will never take over for the simple reason that nowadays people seem to think everyone SHOULD be able to use a computer and if they can't, it is because something is over complicated. Linux treats people like adults but in doing so, demands a certain investment of time in learing how things work and, sadly, many people can't/won't be bothered with it.

Posted at 5:36 a.m. on July 24, 2008


What do you have to say?

Show Editing Help


About

Hello, my name is Zeth, I'll be your host here.

Command Line Warriors is about taking control of your own technology, it looks at our experiences of computing; especially using GNU/Linux, the Python programming language, the command-line and issues such as techno-ethics, best practices and whatever is cool now. If you take control of your technology then you are a Warrior too!

This site is your site too which means that you can contribute and get involved. You can leave comments using the facility provided. For me, the comments and discussions are by far the best part of the site. So please do have your say!

Latest Discussions

Omar Zabaneh

July 25, 2008
Zeth, Thank you for this post, very helpful. I used it as a basis for my own email validation function that i wish to share with you, in a selfish ...
Email Syntax Check in Python

Double Booting Bastard

July 24, 2008
I agree with Nui, Linux is great for many things but not everything. A lot of, less mainstream, hardware is a time consuming and often fruitless task to install and ...
Give Linux a chance

John

July 23, 2008
Duncan, sadly the permissions are stored with the data (inode), not with the directory entries (hard-links). Zeth needs ACLs -- no way to do this with basic unix permissions.
Advanced Unix Groups

Garrick

July 21, 2008
I do love my iPhone. That being said, I would trade it in a heartbeat for a STABLE Openmoko FreeRunner.
This week - iPhone vs a can of compressed air, and Django NewFormsAdmin

Daniel Davies

July 21, 2008
With regards to your last paragraph, you are certainly correct. Right now Django is a nightmare to use across multiple sites... we have some sites running the newformsadmin branch, others ...
This week - iPhone vs a can of compressed air, and Django NewFormsAdmin

Nui

July 18, 2008
Hmm, this would be more persuasive as an argument with some evidence. I am a happy admin of Windows and a novice user of Linux, so I have taken the ...
Give Linux a chance

Paddy3118

July 18, 2008
Hi, I too work with Electronic Design Automation tools, where Tcl is used extensively. I tend to only occasionally have to write in Tcl and so find the TclTutor utility: ...
Python and TCL

Cliff Wells

July 17, 2008
I personally cannot live without the Web Developer extension or Firebug. Unfortunately these are probably both among the more difficult to port extensions. Given how poorly Firefox functions on Linux ...
Will Epiphany be able to compete with Firefox's extensions?

Åke Forslund

July 13, 2008
I'm pretty much a novice in both of these languages but I find them both easy to use and preform the tasks I give them. However I rarely use them ...
Python and TCL

Christopher Thoday

July 12, 2008
A single test is not sufficient to give you confidence that the algorithm is working. You should make 'number' an argument of 'main' so that you can test some boundary ...
Python and TCL

paul21

July 10, 2008
Shame on Mozilla. They should make developers specify the extension license before hosting it. They should show the license next to download button as well.
Are your Firefox extensions proprietary software?

Tris

July 8, 2008
Justin - You say they had not heard of Linux? That doesn't sound very professional to me!
Give Linux a chance

michael

July 8, 2008
what about Galeon? in Gnome i use Galeon mostly. it is fast and stable and has a nice portal with search masks for Debian, FSF, Freshmeat and so on. wtf ...
Will Epiphany be able to compete with Firefox's extensions?

vermin

July 7, 2008
> Eventually, after a bit of digging and Googling, I found their Toolbar-License... You simply found the license of the StumbleUpon Toolbar for Internet Explorer. This is another product, much ...
Are your Firefox extensions proprietary software?

Andrew West

July 6, 2008
Both the Python and the Tcl example could do with error checking. While at first this may not seem on topic with the post I think it better shows the ...
Python and TCL