Don't go to the University of Florida

19 September 2007

Tazering is putting around 3,000 kilovolts into a person with significant chance of heart failure or internal or external burns.

Occasionally you hear about someone who was electrocuted by mains electricity, well that is only 240 volts, not 3,000,000 volts.

The use (or misuse) of Tazers by American police has led to the death of 245 Americans since 2001.

Tazering is not a crowd control weapon, the only correct use is as an alternative to shooting. If the situation is not appropriate for a bullet then it is not appropriate for a Tazer.

Tazers cannot be used on prisoners as it is considered to be cruel and abusive punishment. What is not fit for prisoners is not fit for our brightest young people.

I just watched another video of a non-violent student being needlessly tazered in an American University campus building. A bright 21 year old media student has had his health risked for no good reason at all.

I found out via Andy Lockran's blog. Here is the Youtube link. This video is not so graphic as the UCLA one so hopefully it will not make you sick.

The background was John Kerry who has come on the University campus to give a two hour speech and answer questions.

A student was trying to ask a question, and he starts off by explaining a quote in a book he has read, this is good academic practice to quote and explain yourself, but after about 30 seconds he is rudely being prompted to stop, but he carries on.

I do a bit of audio recording for my University and academic questions can easily be 10 minutes or more. His question was quite rational, he asked about voting irregularities and the disenfranchisement of black voters at the election that Kerry was involved in. Someone who has run for president should be a big enough boy to handle such a question.

However, after another minute he is dragged off by police, handcuffed then held down on the floor and then tazered repeatedly. He is read no rights, nor offered no chance to sit down peacefully. The police just decide to meter out summary punishment.

There are at least five officers holding down the student before they apply the tazer, it was absolutely unnecessary. There are no excuses for this, a guest lecture by a washed-up politician does not warrant risking someone's health.

For his part, John Kerry looks on like a fool, he can see a student being tazered in front of him for asking a question, and he says nothing. Americans should be glad that such a wet fool did not become president. He is a loser in more ways than one.

The University of Florida has failed in their duty of care to their student. They do not seem to care that police brutality happens on their campus. The University of Florida are not worthy of having students go there.

This is not acceptable behaviour, at all. British Universities have boycotted relationships with Universities in developing countries over far less.

Students should be safe at university, at the University of Florida, the harshest thing should be natural orange juice before you add the sugar.

If you are thinking of going to University in America, don't go to the University of Florida, if you are a parent don't send your children there. It seems the University of Florida will not only censor its own students, but it seems that the University of Florida will not guarantee your children's safety but will risk their health by giving them electronic shocks.

If in doubt then send your child to University in Europe, you will find the fees competitive and at least in Britain, Universities do not contain hotheaded police armed with tazers.

The senior administration rushed out a statement saying it regretted the situation, they are right to fear for their positions, one of their students was abused on campus on their watch by police they invited in.

The police tried to save face by holding the student over night in a police cell (why?) but the student was not prosecuted for any crime.

When it hit YouTube and then the mass media, the Florida police department made a U-Turn and some police officers have been suspended on full pay, this is not acceptable, they should be sacked and then prosecuted for assault, the evidence is right here on YouTube. It is a pretty sad day when the police break the peace rather than keep it. These Florida police officers have brought shame on their whole profession.

The police have no right to attack the public, they had not arrested him and had not told him what he was being charged with. If a gang of five normal people grabbed someone, threw them to the floor, held them down and gave them electric shocks, then they would be rightly arrested for assault and/or bodily harm. Therefore these police officers should be prosecuted also.

The Florida University newspaper has a lot more info.

Update, two really interesting views in this post's `comments`_, feel free to `have your say too`_.

1 Steven Nathaniel Oliver says...

Okay, my first comment qualifies as spam according to Akismet, so I'm going to try this again.

I like your post. Its a nice read but I'm afraid I don't agree. An article on the Orlando Sentinel's website sums up view of it better. Its entitled, "Tased student asked for it and got it: Attention" by Mike Thomas.

Posted at 1:14 p.m. on September 20, 2007


2 Albert says...

Steven, I totally disagree. Even if the student was just being obnoxious, that is no reason at all to taser him or arrest him. Although I am not educated in the matters of police practice, I would imagine that the appropriate action on the part of the campus police would have been to first inform the student that they are placing him under protective custody, not arrest. By doing so, they can remove him from the building. To rationalize their action, they could say they felt his level of emotion and questioning had the potential for causing a riot and therefore had to place him under protective custody. While not "cool", it would be justified in my humble opinion.

If he resisted, then they could arrest him.

If he became aggressive or violent, it would only make sense to me for them to use the taser as a way of defending themselves or the other people in the room, not to "shut him up", or punish him.

Posted at 2:56 p.m. on September 20, 2007


What do you have to say?

Show Editing Help


About

Hello, my name is Zeth, I'll be your host here.

Command Line Warriors is about taking control of your own technology, it looks at our experiences of computing; especially using GNU/Linux, the Python programming language, the command-line and issues such as techno-ethics, best practices and whatever is cool now. If you take control of your technology then you are a Warrior too!

This site is your site too which means that you can contribute and get involved. You can leave comments using the facility provided. For me, the comments and discussions are by far the best part of the site. So please do have your say!

Latest Discussions

Nui

July 18, 2008
Hmm, this would be more persuasive as an argument with some evidence. I am a happy admin of Windows and a novice user of Linux, so I have taken the ...
Give Linux a chance

Paddy3118

July 18, 2008
Hi, I too work with Electronic Design Automation tools, where Tcl is used extensively. I tend to only occasionally have to write in Tcl and so find the TclTutor utility: ...
Python and TCL

Cliff Wells

July 17, 2008
I personally cannot live without the Web Developer extension or Firebug. Unfortunately these are probably both among the more difficult to port extensions. Given how poorly Firefox functions on Linux ...
Will Epiphany be able to compete with Firefox's extensions?

making money on the internet

July 17, 2008
[url=http://www.divinecaroline.com/public/user/profile?user_id=83997]extra money 101waystoincome.com[/url]
A year after my 2007 predictions - the score card

Leatherjackets99

July 16, 2008
New Style in Leather Jackets For Man and Woman at http://www.Leatherjackets99.com They Offer Free Shipment Worldwide.
Email Syntax Check in Python

Åke Forslund

July 13, 2008
I'm pretty much a novice in both of these languages but I find them both easy to use and preform the tasks I give them. However I rarely use them ...
Python and TCL

Christopher Thoday

July 12, 2008
A single test is not sufficient to give you confidence that the algorithm is working. You should make 'number' an argument of 'main' so that you can test some boundary ...
Python and TCL

paul21

July 10, 2008
Shame on Mozilla. They should make developers specify the extension license before hosting it. They should show the license next to download button as well.
Are your Firefox extensions proprietary software?

Tris

July 8, 2008
Justin - You say they had not heard of Linux? That doesn't sound very professional to me!
Give Linux a chance

michael

July 8, 2008
what about Galeon? in Gnome i use Galeon mostly. it is fast and stable and has a nice portal with search masks for Debian, FSF, Freshmeat and so on. wtf ...
Will Epiphany be able to compete with Firefox's extensions?

vermin

July 7, 2008
> Eventually, after a bit of digging and Googling, I found their Toolbar-License... You simply found the license of the StumbleUpon Toolbar for Internet Explorer. This is another product, much ...
Are your Firefox extensions proprietary software?

Andrew West

July 6, 2008
Both the Python and the Tcl example could do with error checking. While at first this may not seem on topic with the post I think it better shows the ...
Python and TCL

Kurushiyama

June 30, 2008
XML is no replacement for SGML, it's a subset.
An Introduction to ReStructuredText